POLK COUNTY, Fla. (WFLA) – Authorities have arrested more than 100 people in an undercover sting targeting prostitution, human trafficking and child predators in Polk County, Florida, including a pastor and two people who work at Orlando theme parks.
The six-day investigation, dubbed “Operation Santa’s Naughty List,” aimed to identify and help victims of human trafficking who might have been forced into prostitution.
“I, in my heart, believe that every one of these prostitutes at some point in their time in their life were a victim of human trafficking, if in fact, they’re not currently a victim of human trafficking,” said Sheriff Grady Judd.
Sheriff Judd said a number of people answered online advertisements and arranged to meet with undercover detectives at a location in Polk County.
Detectives arrested a Disney security guard named Rodney Davis, 56, of Winter Garden on a charge of soliciting prostitution.
“This guy walked up to the front door of this home in a neighborhood on a cool evening buck naked,” said Sheriff Judd.
A video shows how his arrest unfolded.
A total of 124 people were arrested, five of which had the intent to sexually harm a child, Judd said. Fifty-three people were arrested for prostitution, a second-degree misdemeanor, and 46 were arrested for seeking the services of a prostitute, a first-degree misdemeanor, Judd said.
The investigators also arrested Tommy Gainey, a professional golfer and member of the PGA.
He told the sheriff’s office he was in town for a charity golf event.
“He missed his tee time the next morning,” said Sheriff Judd.
Eighteen people were arrested on various other charges, including aiding/transporting/deriving proceeds from prostitution.
Seven men were charged with soliciting prostitution involving children, including:
- Anthony Gavin, 33, of Davenport: Investigators said he thought he was chatting online with a 14-year-old boy when he said, “I don’t wanna be labeled a pedophile.” Gavin brought condoms to the location, and when he was arrested, he told detectives that he was there, “because I’m stupid,” according to investigators.
- Pierre Alvarez, 21, of Davenport believed he was communicating online with a 12-year-old girl, investigators said. Judd said he sent nude photos of himself and discussed what he would like to do to the girl, then rode his bicycle to meet her. He had a condom in his pocket when he was arrested.
- Demitrus Gonzalez, 26, of Davenport, contacted an undercover detective, thinking that he was chatting with a 14-year-old boy, investigators said. Gonzalez drove to the operation and brought lubricant, condoms and Xanax with him. While being arrested, he bit a Lakeland Police Officer on the hand, Judd said.
- Joshua Bryant, 23, from Brandon, thought he was talking to a 14-year-old boy online and sent three nude photos and tried to arrange to pick up the boy, investigators said. Bryant reportedly told the boy to sneak out of the house and that he could hide at Bryant’s house if he was reported missing. After arriving at the location, Bryant got suspicious and collided with an undercover vehicle as he was trying to drive away, investigators said.
- Benjamin Castaneda, 24, of Orlando, allegedly made contact with who he thought was a 13-year-old girl online. In his texts, Castaneda wasted no time telling the undercover detective what he wanted to do with the girl, investigators said. He drove to the location and arrived less than two hours after making initial contact and was arrested. He is a waiter at a Universal Studios restaurant, Judd said.
- Matthew Minardi, 22, from Palm Harbor, began a sexually-explicit conversation via social media with who he thought were two different 13-year-old girls but both were actually undercover detectives, according to investigators. Minardi also reportedly sent a nude image of himself. He did not travel to the operation location but was located and arrested by the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office.
- William Stemmermann, 53, from Kissimmee, chatted with and called an undercover detective, thinking she was a 13-year-old girl, according to investigators. He attempted to arrange to meet and requested photos to be sent to him, they said.. Stemmermann did not travel to the operation location but was located and arrested in Kissimmee.
Of those arrested, 30 were married and one was engaged. Seven suspects had traveled to Polk County from other states, and one person was visiting from Ontario, Canada, Judd said.
The oldest was 70, while the youngest was 19 years old, according to Judd.
Judd said seven women who were arrested for prostitution may be the victims of human trafficking. Two of the women were taken to shelters and introduced to anti-trafficking organizations for assistance and support.
Advocates say people selling sex can benefit from their arrest as well.
“The violence against them is going to be stopping for tonight. They’re going to be hearing about services,” said Christa Lynn, an advocate at One More Child.