Woman Says She Was Refused an Ambulance

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 6/25/2010 11:49 pm
Karen Alves is finally home. For the last two weeks, the Warren woman says she has been in the Cleveland VA hospital being treated for pneumonia. Even though she is now recuperating, she said she  is extremely concerned that she was unable to get an ambulance when she fell ill earlier this month.

Alves, who works for the state of Ohio helping veterans, said it was close to midnight on June 11 when she woke up with an extremely high fever. She said she was disoriented and dizzy and called 911.
         
She was transferred to a dispatcher at MedStar, who first said he was unable to send an ambulance just for a fever.

"It is just a shame they would not send an ambulance," said Alves. "One of the things I told the gentleman is that I am a veteran. I served my country, and all I want is an ambulance, an ambulance escort."

Alves' mother, who lives in Boston, also called MedStar begging for an ambulance, and about 20 minutes later one was sent, but Alves had already driven herself to a local hospital. 

Joe Robinson, president of MedStar, said he is reviewing the case.

"We have been under a lot of scrutiny lately in the press in regards to our 911 contract in the city of Warren, and a lot of it has to do with trying to eliminate those calls. So we are available for the real true blue emergencies."

Robinson said the company does the very best it can to make sure everyone is served.

Mayor Mike O'Brien said the city will look into the matter to ensure that ambulance service needs are available to city residents, either through the ambulance contract or adjoining fire districts.

Share
8 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

jd3577 - 6/28/2010 10:07 AM
OH, and while I am still stewing atop my soap box, SHAME ON YOU WKBN for wasting my time with a garbage article like this one! I would rather watch my seven year old son throw a temper tantrum in person than read it here or see it on the news.

jd3577 - 6/26/2010 11:07 AM
Donjj...... just so you know the EMD protocol that was apparently followed was written by a doctor!!!!! This is why I just sit back and laugh directly AT you.

jd3577 - 6/26/2010 10:45 AM
And so it begins. A fever is ABSOLUTELY no need for an ambulance. For that matter neither is pneumonia. A ride by car to your family doctor is what is needed to treat that. Emergency departments are NOT doctor's offices. Why can't people understand that? As for being "just a dispatcher or just an EMT" stupid comments like that are just inflammatory and immediately disregarded. I challenge you to come out and spend a shift with me. Maybe all you need is a bit of education on this topic. I hate to have to deny an ambulance to someone calling because their child quit breathing, or because they just witnessed a crash or shooting or any other EMERGENCY. Why would they not send an ambulance to something like that????? Because they were too busy taking someone who was "entitled" to an ambulance to the hospital. who had a fever or possible pneumonia. Doctors have cool things like answering services for after hours services. If you call your doctor they are going to tell you to go to the ER.....get a ride in a car. Final thought.....when you call an ambulance for non emergency, family doctor or dentist type complaints, thinking you will get in faster or go "straight to the back," you're sadly mistaken. You DO go directly through the ER initially, but that's on your way out to the lobby.

reno 48 - 6/26/2010 10:26 AM
I smell a lawsuit somewhere.This is blown way out of proportion.Get in line for a lawsuit honey.

mojo21 - 6/26/2010 9:02 AM
With every moron out there now using ambulances as taxi's to get seen quicker in the emergency room what do you expect. Ambulances are not cabs! They are for life and death emergencies! If she drove HERSELF to the hospital then she DID NOT NEED AN AMBULANCE!!! She was ambulatory. But heh, sue for free money. Why not? easier than welfare.

db2sub1 - 6/26/2010 8:54 AM
These ambulance folks are used as taxi cabs so much by lowlife trash that when they receive a call 'for a fever' they, of course, are going to refuse. If Ms. Alves was so sick from pneumonia why did she neglect going to a doctor sooner? Looks like Ms. Alves shares the blame here.

DonJJ - 6/25/2010 11:55 PM
"just a fever"???? The jerk at Medstar should have ignored whoever told him to follow those guidelines! Sheesh! A monkey would know better. Fevers often are the first symptoms of some serious problems. I vote to throw out MedStar and then sue the tires off of the company.

sunny - 6/25/2010 10:15 PM
Couldn't send one for a fever - jerks! My first husband died of pnemonia - if he had gotten medical attention sooner (his fault), they may have discovered it was bacterial pnemonia in time to give him the correct medications~~~if you are getting paid for your service, how the h*ll do you justify denying anyone service, especially given the fact that you are only dispatchers and EMTs - not doctors - you have no right, legal or moral to determine that this person didn't need help!
Most Popular
Two Dogs Dropped from I-680 Bridge
Two dogs reportedly were dropped from the bridge above Midlothian Boulevard on Monday. Police are still looking for the suspects. Click on the video player below to see an interview with two witnesses. Video
Pickup Truck Suspended by Wires
A pickup truck is suspended by wires after the driver hits a utility pole in Austintown. Video
Trumbull Subway Operators Sued for Labor Violations
The U.S. Department of Labor alleges that the operators of five Subways in Trumbull County violated minimum wage and child labor laws.
News Poll
Connect with WKBN
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.