Rescues Hopeful Dog Auctions will be Banned in 2012

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 12/31/2010 7:07 am
At shelters, such as Angels for Animals, dogs wait to be adopted into loving families.

But that's not always the case at dog auctions, where purebreds are sold for as little as $1.

"They're mostly around Holmes County, and the problem is they're kept in very poor conditions," said Matt Ditchey, Angels for Animals trustee. "It's just not a good thing for the dogs."

Two years ago, people opposed to dog auctions tried to get a ban on the ballot. Last year, they only collected about 7,000 signatures. This year, they brought in 77,000, which is a lot, but not the 121,000 needed.

"We're doing it as an all-volunteer effort," Ditchey said. "We could have easily just paid people to do it, but we want to have people that are Ohioans and people who really believe in the cause that do the work."

Ditchey said he's confident Ohioans will see the issue on the ballot in 2012.

"We get very, very positive response from people. Most of the official holders in Mahoning County signed the petition, as did congressmen and the like," he said.

But not everyone agrees with the ban. The Ohio Association for Animal Owners wouldn't talk to us on camera, but they say such a ban would be an "attack on commerce" and that dog auctions are well-monitored. But Ditchey said that's simply not true.

"Well monitored? That's silly," Ditchey said. "That's not even remotely true. They're poorly monitored. If you took your news cameras down there and tried to get in, you'd be shown the door very quickly."

Dog auctions are already banned in some states, especially along the East Coast. They're most prevalent in the Midwest.
Share
8 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

CanineFancy - 12/31/2010 11:25 PM
2 Votes
One additional correction: The Amish do receive FREE medical care in many of the Ohio hospitals, even though they do not pay federal taxes. Just ask many of the hospital volunteers from Wadsworth Ohio. Catzrule, you obviously didn't hear about the $33 MILLION dollar Ponzi scheme perpetrated by Amish 'investment counselor', Mr. Beachy! You can't ASSume all of the Amish are a hard working group of people who take care of themselves and do not look toward our Government for a free ride. That's like saying all Irish drink too much or all African American men are members of gangs. Beachy embezzled this money from over 2,000 Amish and Mennonite investors from Northeast Ohio who are now under investigation by the IRS, SEC, Ohio Department of Taxation and many other legal authorities.

CanineFancy - 12/31/2010 11:16 PM
2 Votes
I am helping with this ballot referendum. The 7,000 signatures was gathered from November 2, 2009 (official start of the signature gathering)- December 11, 2009, so it only represents one month not an entire year. Well policed already? I have been to these auctions and have witnessed first hand dogs that have been sold with brucellosis, ear and eye infections, pyometra, broken bones and fevers. This last auction sold over 480 dogs in six hours, and over 300 of them were consigned by one of the worst puppy mill breeders from Minnesota. Her USDA inspection reports can be viewed online through USDA-APHIS. Do we really want commerce in Ohio that allows people convicted of animal cruelty to buy and sell dogs? I for one do not! I will be helping to collect the remaining signatures to get this to the ballot in 2012. Correction to Karen; the Amish do NOT pay federal taxes (they do not collect Social Security, unemployment, or welfare benefits). Also, the Ohio Department of Taxation conducted an audit in 2009 of all the commercial breeders and discovered that many Amish breeders did not pay their sales tax. The total amount uncollected for all the breeders (of which the Amish breeders represent 54%) was over half a million dollars! The dog auctions serve as a major distribution channel for an industry fueled by animal abuse, corruption and consumer fraud. There is plenty of evidence through USDA inspection reports, veterinary records and the like to support why 9/10 voters are signing this initiative petition. They include farmers, hunters, dog fanciers and many other voting blocs that do not consider themselves 'animal rights.'

KarenD - 12/31/2010 7:05 PM
0 Votes
Responding to "becauseisaidso"... Contrary to what you and almost everyone else in the country believes, THE AMISH PEOPLE DO PAY TAXES!! They pay property tax, they pay sales tax, they pay self-employment tax. If you don't believe it, go to ANY Amish community during tax time and see how many Amish are in the tax offices. How do I know this? I work for them. I get a Form 1099 at the end of the year just like you get a W-2 (if you're employed). My employer (an Amish roofing crew) reports my earnings just as his get reported by the contractors that he works for. And how do I know he pays property tax?? Because, #1, he complains about how high his taxes are, and #2, it's a matter of public record... Look it up on any county auditor's website. Now, while I agree that the puppy mills should be stopped, it's not only the Amish that have them. There's one in Southington that's not Amish - I have a friend that bought a puppy from there, not knowing it was a mill ahead of time. The puppy died after 4 months because of the care (or lack of) that it got at the mill. If more people checked their facts before responding to these articles, maybe they wouldn't look so dumb.......

REDEYE1 - 12/31/2010 3:23 PM
0 Votes
Isn't it amazing that a few people don't like it , they want it banned. If they ban it , then let's put laws on all animal pounds through the state. Make it impossible for them to operate, then everyone will HAPPY LOL

catzrule - 12/31/2010 11:10 AM
0 Votes
and use all our amentities but reuse to pay for them... ************* I know many Amish from dealing with them over the years and have not heard of one yet who was on welfare, food stamps, unemployment, free healthcare, section 8 housing, or social security. They are a hard working group of people who take care of themselves and do not look toward our Government for a free ride.

becauseisaidso - 12/31/2010 7:06 AM
3 Votes
Dog auctions should be banned. The puppies come from puppy mills. Most are amish you know the people who dont pay taxes, dont fight for our country and use all our amentities but reuse to pay for them...tax the bastards! Ohio shamefully ranks number two in USA for puppy mills. The horrors these dogs live through for the sake for profit is unbelievable. Just google puppy mills in OH and see what you get. Because Ohio does not have regulations all the scum from out of state are dumping their crap on Ohio. Below is a link of what an news investigation did on Ohio Puppy mill dog auctions. These people could care less about the well being of animals as long as they make a buck. Sadly as long as people are foolish enough to pay bigbucks for MUTTS at the puppy mills retail outlets stores here, like harbor pet, or online, they will continue to breed MUTTS and sell them to fools. Hopefully OH lawmakers will get a law passed t protect consumers in OH from these people amd to protect the animals. as a person who donates time, money and volunteers at local shelters, we say dont breed or buy while pets in shelters/pounds die...adopt. http://www.whas11.com/news/I-Team-Investigation-Inside-the-multi-million-dollar-business-of-dog-auctions-94864294.html

annaakita - 12/31/2010 3:24 AM
0 Votes
Its called the US isnt as free as we were supposed to be. The government is taking more and more away from us every single day. I'm so sick of the "animal rights" when we have "people issues" going on that need fixed before the property does...

Biker Mike - 12/30/2010 11:15 PM
0 Votes
Look people,STOP LETTING PEOPLE MAKE DECISIONS FOR YOU !!!!! If the amounts of money being bid on these breeds are not sufficient for the type of dog then create a minimum bid on this type of auction.Stop making laws taking people's rights away from them.Every day someone is taking away someone's rights.One day it will be one of your rights that you care about.Start thinking about what is happening around you instead of taking away the rights of someone else !!!!!!
More Local Stories
Kitten Shot in Face with BB Gun, Dumped on East Side
Officials with Animal Charity said the four-week-old kitten was found Monday. She is expected to be OK, but may have damage to her eyes.
East Liverpool Fire that Killed 4 Ruled Murder-Suicide
Ulrick Estimot, 37, and his three sons Trey, 11, Terrell, 7, and Trenton, 5, died in the fire at their home back in March.
Tip of Woman's Finger Bitten Off During Scuffle in Warren
A woman said four other females surrounded her car, dragged her out and assaulted her early Monday.
News Poll
What's on WKBN?
On Now
Let's Make a Deal
Coming Up Tonight...
7:00PM 
Wheel of Fortune
7:30PM 
Jeopardy!
8:00PM 
NCIS: Los Angeles
9:00PM 
NCIS
10:00PM 
NCIS
Connect with WKBN
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.