Parents Accuse Officer of Racially Profiling Boys

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 3/30/2010 9:07 am
The Simmons boys, ages 7, 9, and 10, were walking home from school Friday afternoon in Warren when they noticed a police cruiser nearby.

The boys didn't pay much attention to the cop car, but the officer driving noticed them and called 911 dispatch.

"(Breaking and entering) in progress, three black males down Atlantic Street," the officer told dispatch.

Moments after spotting the cruiser, the boys, who were in the backyard of their Sarkies Drive home, said the cop came up to them.

"He walked up with his gun and ordered us down on the ground in the mud," said 10-year-old Tony Simmons.

The boys said the cop asked them what was in 9-year-old Stephen's backpack. When the boy replied he had just school papers, the cop went through it and then tossed it on the ground, the boys said.

During an interview at their home Monday morning, the boys said they had no idea why they were held at gunpoint.

"Like I just wanted someone to come help us," said 7-year-old David. "I was really scared. I didn't know what the cop was going to do to us."

His brother, Stephen, agreed.

"I was scared, and I was just wondering when my dad was going to come," Stephen said.

When the boys' father got outside, the officer told him the boys were stopped because there had been several burglaries in the area.

"We are the only black family in the area," said Carolyn Simmons, the boys' mother. "There are other children here and for some reason it was my family that was picked on."

The boys' parents believe their children were victims of racial profiling. The parents have filed a formal complaint against the officer. The complaint will not be released until the officer is served. The officer is off and has not yet given his side to investigators.

The boys were not charged.

Sgt. Jeff Cole, of internal affairs, said the officer was on routine patrol and not responding to a call at the time of the incident. He hopes to have the investigation completed in the next few weeks.

Share
15 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

db2sub1 - 3/31/2010 7:26 AM
0 Votes
I find it hard to believe that a grown man is going to pull a gun on three small children. A trained police officer in uniform. Nope, I don't buy it. Maybe Attorney Betras is fishing for his next payday or some young Al Sharpton wannabe is looking for a platform but this reeks to high heaven.

ArmyRetired - 3/30/2010 11:10 PM
0 Votes
It appears to be a classic case of racial profiling to me. However, the clip did not give us the entire story. Did other officiers ever arrive at the scene? Did the mere appearance of the young boys' father provide the officer(s) with sufficient proof as the boys' identity and innocence? Why didn't the officer stop them on the street? The 911 call did report a robbery or burglary in progress and more or less that he was in pursuit of three robbery or burglary suspects, correct? So one would think that if the officer in fact witnessed them actually committing the crime, then why were the boys not held, arrested or charged? But let's just say that the boys were running down the street, and a burglary had just taken place and been reported, I would like to know how closely they matched to suspects? I am not a police officer but I know their jobs are dangerous, but I also this could have and should have been handled differently. These children are scarred for life! This police drew his weapon on them unnecessarily and unlawfully. Fortunately, these parents had instilled in their children respect the law and law enforcement officers, otherwise they may have unknowingly made a "false" move and been blown away. When we hear the officer side of the story and the investigation is complete, I trust that a formal apology, counseling for these young boys, and the officer's termination would be forthcoming.

stefluvs2sign - 3/30/2010 10:22 PM
0 Votes
I am a friend of the family and I am WHITE so I don't want anyone to think I am pulling the race card. These are the most well mannered & well behaved children regardless of the color of their skin. They were in in THEIR OWN backyard PUBLIC WATCHER! A backyard that my kids have played in and built snowmen. Read above where it says their father came outside, he saw it happening. Why didn't the officer knock on the door and ask the homeowner if they knew there were children in the backyard? Also, since they are the only black family in the neighborhood, I am quite sure the police know where they live. These kids are too young to have to deal with this so early in life. To the person that said they would become criminals because of this, trust me, not these boys. Darn well bet they become lawyers, they come from a good family. A family that will teach them to forgive but not forget, a family with morals, values, and ethics. Perhaps the policeman should have been brought up the same way.

Fancy - 3/30/2010 8:38 PM
1 Vote
The police do profile people of color. Just because the person or persons are black ,does not give them or anyone to think thay are a criminal. And to pull a gun on a child it outrages me as a citizen in this county. The cop needs his stupid ass fired NOW!!!!

brngsxybck09 - 3/30/2010 6:40 PM
1 Vote
ok seriously public watcher nothing those boys were doing in there back yard at there HOME could excuse a cop ANY COP pulling a gun on a 7 9 and 10 year old boys. be seriouse for a minute and think about how if the cop was actually doing his job and there was no foul play we woulod have his story by now i mean if he did nothing wrng thn why not come forward!!!!!

public watcher - 3/30/2010 4:45 PM
0 Votes
WOW, it even says in the article that the officers side has not been heard yet, but yet we take the sides of 3 young children and deem this officer in the wrong based on one side of the story, i hate the way cops act as if they do no wrong or abuse there power but thats not always the case, lets get the full story from both sides before we jump to conclusions. always has to be racial something somewhere usually by the black racist who complain inequality, get over it and get the facts...

Votingcitizen - 3/30/2010 3:28 PM
0 Votes
vrobert, great point. Officers need to remember they are the example.

vrobertc - 3/30/2010 2:35 PM
3 Votes
There is a possibility this poor excuse for a Law Enforcement Officer,helped create 3 criminals,as I am sure they wont have a positive view of law enforcement as I stll have,however my father was a police chief and instilled in me that Officers should set the example and are in place to improve society. Nothing has changed.

Votingcitizen - 3/30/2010 1:20 PM
1 Vote
Finally 3 little victims who are completely innocent. no chance for WPD to distract us with lies about why their officers are justified in doing this. I feel terrible for those little boys, nothing about them fits any sort of stereotype that would make a rational person thing they were up to no good, let alone in their own backyard. I respect the police, but this officer has to go and it's time for a complete cleanup of the WPD. If their union really cared about protecting and serving they would stop defending this bad eggs.

vrobertc - 3/30/2010 11:35 AM
2 Votes
Although I believe in law and order,it seems that some of the people picked for law enforcement,should be collecting garbage instead, he not only should be fired ,he should spend time in JAIL.
More Local Stories
Kitten Shot in Face with BB Gun, Dumped on East Side
Officials with Animal Charity said the four-week-old kitten was found Monday. She is expected to be OK, but may have damage to her eyes.
East Liverpool Fire that Killed 4 Ruled Murder-Suicide
Ulrick Estimot, 37, and his three sons Trey, 11, Terrell, 7, and Trenton, 5, died in the fire at their home back in March.
Tip of Woman's Finger Bitten Off During Scuffle in Warren
A woman said four other females surrounded her car, dragged her out and assaulted her early Monday.
News Poll
What's on WKBN?
On Now
Let's Make a Deal
Coming Up Tonight...
7:00PM 
Wheel of Fortune
7:30PM 
Jeopardy!
8:00PM 
NCIS: Los Angeles
9:00PM 
NCIS
10:00PM 
NCIS
Connect with WKBN
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.